clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Indians vs. Padres recap: Trevor Bauer sharp, but Tribe falls 2-1

Trevor Bauer held up his part of the bargain, but he was just about the only one.

Jason Miller

Game 9: Padres 2, Indians 1

Trevor Bauer, who was called up in order to make a spot start necessitated by Monday's rain out, pitched a very good game. He went 6 innings, struck out 8, and allowed just 4 hits and 2 walks, leading to 2 runs (one of which was unearned, on account of an Asdrubal Cabrera error). There's a good argument that it was the best game Bauer has pitched in an Indians uniform.

Not only did the Cabrera error lead to one of those runs, there was also a strange play in which Indians right fielder Elliot Johnson made a catch near the wall, then dropped the ball while transferring it to his throwing hand, and had the umpire rule that it was not a catch. Take a look:

That's a catch.

MLB rules state a player must complete a transfer from glove to hand before a play is deemed an out, but there has to be a limit on that. After all, Johnson took two or three steps with the ball in his glove, then stopped and turned before the ball came out.


The Tribe offense floundered, putting only 8 men on base all game. A sacrifice fly in the 3rd inning scored a run, but the next real scoring opportunity didn't come until the 9th inning, when Ryan Raburn singled, pinch runner Nyjer Morgan stole second, and Michael Brantley drew a walk to put runners on 1st and 2nd with one out. Yan Gomes hit an easy fly ball for the second out though, and Cabrera did the same thing for out number three, ending the game.

I would really have liked to see Lonnie Chisenhall pinch hit for Cabrera, because Lonnie (the reigning Indians PLayer of the Week) has been swinging the bat much better and is probably a better hitter against righties than Cabrera even if you ignore the small sample of this season's early results. Instead, the Indians played 18 innings this afternoon and Chisenhall never had reason to get off the bench beyond passing out a few high fives.

Bauer looked as good as we could have hoped, after also doing well in his first start of the season (for Columbus). I don't think we should read too much into things just yet, but if he puts together a couple more good outing for the Clippers, he could be knocking on the door for a permanent promotion.

The Indians are now 5-4, and will leave town in the morning for a big road trip that takes them to Chicago for 4 games and then to Detroit for 3. Let's hope they return home next week with their winning record still intact.

Box Score

Win-expectancy chart:

Source: FanGraphs

Roll Call:

Game Thread

Total comments: 705

Total commenters: 55

# Commenter # Comments
1 PyroKinesis 51
2 Cols714 40
3 no1ever 38
4 JulioBernazard 37
5 mjschaefer 36
6 InMyLifetime? 36
7 USSChoo 33
8 LosIndios 27
9 supermarioelia 23
10 westbrook 21
11 Phil Kehres 19
12 jayme 19
13 emd2k3 18
14 Josh Finney 17
15 tribelover 17
16 Ty Beatty 16
17 7foot3 14
18 Ryan 14
19 Deebo Jones 14
20 mauichuck 14
21 tgriffith1992 14
22 ZeCarioca 13
23 tr1betime 13
24 CTTribe73 11
25 Gradyforpresident 10
26 Matt Y. 10
27 APV 10
28 ahowie 10
29 Zaza Braggins 10
30 Chief Wahoo 8
31 JimmyAB 8
32 lucasmcain 8
33 PaduaDSP 8
34 rolub 7
35 dgcambridge 6
36 Ockus_NYC 6
37 T.O. Tribe 6
38 hans 5
39 mtg8 5
40 #RollTribe 3
41 JLK14 3
42 jrandall64 3
43 NatiTribeFan 3
44 Denver Tribe Fan 3
45 pezzicle 3
46 rock7413 2
47 palcal 2
48 BuenosAires_Dawg 2
49 FredOx 2
50 broseph85 2
51 weareallkipnisses 1
52 bantrybay 1
53 OPace 1
54 mcrose 1
55 Conrad Kaczmarek 1