clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Corey Kluber roughed up as Cleveland Indians fall 6-2 in coldest Opening Day in team history

What started out as a frigid pitching duel quickly turned into a minor blowout.

Jason Miller/Getty Images

Indians 2, Red Sox 6

Box Score

Indians fall to 0-1


The Cleveland Indians second attempt at an Opening Day, after Monday's failed due to terrible weather, did not quite go as planned. What started out looking like a battle between aces David Price and Corey Kluber on a frigid 35-degree day ultimately turned into the Tribe's former Cy Young-winner getting roughed up the second and third time through the vicious lineup of the Boston Red Sox.

Both Kluber and Price were masterful in the first couple innings. Price even carried a no-hitter into the fourth (which I, personally, ruined), and Kluber was looking good other than a few scattered hits here and there. It was not until the second time through the order when Kluber began to have trouble, especially against leadoff hitter Mookie Betts.

Betts' two-run home run that scored No. 9 hitter Jackie Bradley Jr. opened the scoring of the game and signaled what the next few innings of the game would be like for Kluber -- a whole lot of difficulty. Kluber was finally knocked out of the game after five and two-thirds innings following a wild pitch and a walk against back-to-back opponents. To their credit, everyone in the bullpen not named Trevor Bauer held tight for the rest of the game (including newcomer Ross Detwiler surviving a bases-loaded situation in the seventh), but the Indians offense was not there late in the game to mount a comeback.

For the most part, the offense looked lethargic, especially once they lost the lead after tying it 2-2. The one shining aspect of the lineup was Mike Napoli, who consistently made Price work for his outs. Napoli fought through a 15-pitch at-bat in the fourth inning that helped the Tribe score their only two runs of the game. The back-to-back combination of Napoli and Carlos Santana should be very annoying throughout the season if it does not end up being downright deadly. Napoli wearing down a pitcher and Santana either doing the same or knocking runners home with a moonshot should be a common sight over the next 161 games.

Speaking of Santana, he showed some great baserunning in that run-scoring fourth inning. He made it all the way from first to third on a hit by Marlon Byrd that barely made it into the outfield. For any runner not with his head up and showing great awareness, he probably would have been stuck at third, or even second base. But Santana saw the opportunity and he was flying from the  moment the ball left Byrd's bat.

One of the biggest questions heading into today's game (and the season) is how the outfield would hold up and it... wasn't pretty. Defensively, they were not challenged much. Byrd had a great grab in the outfield that he had to track down deep into left field, but other than that it was mostly routine balls that probably would have been home runs knocked down by heavy winds.

The entire outfield group (including Naquin who debuted with a pinch-hit opportunity) were a combined 0-for-9 with eight strikeouts. If the Indians are going to avoid yet another slow start, they need the group to do better over the next week while Chisenhall and Brantley recover. Otherwise, the Indians will have a huge hole to dig out of when everyone is healthy again in May.

It may not be the outcome we wanted, but baseball is back. At least for a day I would say it's okay to accept a loss and still be happy. Maybe not if you were there and freezing to death, but for me, sitting under my daughter's warm Frozen blanket, it was a constant joy.

Run expectancy chart

Source: FanGraphs

Roll Call

Roll Call Info
Total comments 506
Total commenters 53
Commenter list 7foot3, APV, AmbienTribe8, Andrew Kinsman, BGBrownsFan, Benedict Arnold, Brick., Denver Tribe Fan, DocNo, GratefulDawg, Jay, Joel D, Josh Finney, LosIndios, Matt R. Lyons, Matt Y., MooneysRebellion, Pa tribefan, PaduaDSP, PaulHoynes'Mustache, PortlandVinny, PyroKinesis, ROXXFOXXSPORTS, RabbiHick, Roger Dorn, Ryan, Vachos, YoDaddyWags, Zaza Braggins, _thenick, baerga1, barsham, brookjacoby, bschwartz, emd2k3, emily522, hans, keenej, lucasmcain, mainstreetfan, mjschaefer, new zealand tribe fan, no1ever, notthatnoise, palcal, pezzicle, playdoh, rolub, sly5311, tgriffith1992, tr1betime, tribelover, westbrook
Story URLs
# Commenter # Comments
1 Zaza Braggins 52
2 PyroKinesis 47
3 Brick. 37
4 tgriffith1992 28
5 tr1betime 22
6 Ryan 21
7 emily522 18
8 PaulHoynes'Mustache 18
9 Roger Dorn 16
10 Vachos 16
11 PaduaDSP 15
12 YoDaddyWags 15
13 Josh Finney 15
14 GratefulDawg 14
15 MooneysRebellion 14
16 BGBrownsFan 12
17 bschwartz 12
18 7foot3 11
19 keenej 10
20 Jay 8
21 mainstreetfan 7
22 barsham 7
23 lucasmcain 6
24 baerga1 6
25 no1ever 6
26 notthatnoise 5
27 APV 5
28 RabbiHick 4
29 Denver Tribe Fan 4
30 new zealand tribe fan 4
31 LosIndios 4
32 Andrew Kinsman 4
33 DocNo 3
34 emd2k3 3
35 pezzicle 3
36 PortlandVinny 3
37 _thenick 3
38 westbrook 3
39 tribelover 3
40 rolub 3
41 mjschaefer 2
42 palcal 2
43 Matt R. Lyons 2
45 Pa tribefan 2
46 sly5311 2
47 playdoh 1
48 hans 1
49 Joel D 1
50 AmbienTribe8 1
51 Benedict Arnold 1
52 brookjacoby 1
53 Matt Y. 1