clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Corey Kluber or Jason Kipnis, how do you choose?

No matter which way you go, you're passing on someone who was tremendous last week.

Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

Each week I select someone as the Cleveland Indians' top player of the previous week. Then, because this is a dictatorship, but not a totalitarian one, I let you all have your say as well. Some weeks it's a no-brainer, while other weeks there are multiple guys with a strong case. (Occasionally there are weeks when no one has a strong case.)

Previous winners:

  • April 6-12: Carlos Santana (my choice, and by a single vote, winner of the voting)
  • April 20-26: Brandon Moss (my choice), Michael Brantley (reader vote)
  • May 4-10: Danny Salazar (my choice), Jason Kipnis (reader vote)

The Indians won back-to-back games for the first time since the season's first series, but are still looking for their first winning week of the year. Along with three victories, last week brought some of the most impressive numbers we've seen from anyone on the team all season. I've included the usual four candidates, but this is a two-man race. Whichever one you vote for is a great choice, as is the one you don't vote for. This is a tough decision.

The Candidates

Trevor Bauer

Bauer struck out 10 in 7.1 innings against the Cardinals on Thursday, while allowing only one run. That's a great pitching performance... but, it's obviously not the best pitching performance the Tribe had last week. It's an honor just to be nominated though, right?

Michael Brantley

Brantley batted .381/.500/,762, with a wRC+ of 235 in 28 plate appearances last week. He scored 5 runs and drove in 6. He homered and stole a base. That's a great week at the plate... but it's obviously not the best week at the plate the Tribe had last week. A nomination is nothing to shake your head about though, is it?

Jason Kipnis

Kipnis continued his tremendous stretch of baseball with his best week yet, batting .583/.667/.875, with a wRC+ of 333 in 31 plate appearances. He reached base safely at least twice thrice in all six games, with a total of 14 hits for the week, including 4 doubles and a home run. He drove in 3 runs and scored 8. On Saturday against Texas, Kipnis had 3 hits, including a 9th inning home run that put the Tribe ahead in what had been a tie game. It was the best week at the plate anyone on the team has had this season.

Corey Kluber

Kluber took the mound Wednesday against St. Louis and turned in one of the best pitching performances in franchise history, striking out 18 batters while walking 0 and allowing no runs on only 1 hit in 8 innings. (That gave him a FIP of -0.97 for the week). He had a chance at the MLB strikeout record, but was pulled before the 9th due to having already thrown a season-high 113 pitches.

The Verdict

I don't think that in the time I've been doing this there have ever been two players so deserving of the honor. The easy way out would be to name them both winners.Like Ike and Tina though, I never ever do nothing nice and easy*. FanGraphs has Kipnis' week as being worth slightly more, giving him 1.0 WAR, while Kluber comes in at 0.8. That would be a reasonable way to decide things. I keeping coming back to Kluber though. His Game Score was 98, which is the highest ever for a start that didn't last 9 innings, and is the highest by an Indians pitcher in a game of any length since Luis Tiant reached 99 in a 10-inning start in 1969. (Tiant struck out 19 in that game.) I feel terrible about shorting Kipnis, but I'm siding with the Klubot.

*Not true

Congratulations, Corey!