clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Lonnie Chisenhall and Bryan Shaw each had a big week for the Indians

Some weeks I know who I'm going to pick before I even sit down to start working on this post. This was not one of those weeks.

David Richard-USA TODAY Sports


It's time for our weekly look at the Indians' top players of the last seven days, in which one man is chosen as better than the rest. Be sure to vote for you choice in the poll included at the bottom.

Previous winners:

  • March 31-April 6: L.Chisenhall
  • April 7-13: D.Murphy
  • April 14-20: M.Brantley
  • April 21-27: C.Kluber
  • April 28-May 4: C.Santana
  • May 5-11: M.Brantley (editorial pick), J.Tomlin (reader vote)
  • May 12-18: D.Murphy
  • May 19-25: L.Chisenhall (editorial pick), C.Kluber (reader vote)
  • May 26-June 1: T.House (editorial pick), C.Kluber (reader vote)
  • June 2-8: J.Masterson (editorial pick), L.Chisenhall (reader vote)
  • June 9-15: M.Brantley
  • June 16-22: C.Santana
  • June 23-29: J.Tomlin
  • June 30-July 6: C.Kluber
  • July 7-13: T.Bauer
  • July 14-20: J.Kipnis
  • July 21-27: C.Santana
  • July 28-August 3: C.Kluber
  • August 4-10: C.Kluber
  • August 11-17: C.Carrasco
  • August 18-24: J.Ramirez
  • The Candidates

    It's been almost three months since the reader vote picked a different player than I did, but it wouldn't surprise me if it happened this week, because multiple players have a very strong case in what was one of the best weeks of the season for the Tribe.

    Carlos Carrasco

    Carrasco continued his best stretch in more than three years (and maybe ever at the MLB level) with another very good start Thursday night in Chicago. He gave up only 1 run in 6.2 innings, with 7 strikeouts and only 4 hits and 1 walk allowed.

    Lonnie Chisenhall

    Chisenhall hit .462/.500/.846 in 14 PA for the week, with at least one hit in all five of the games he appeared in. Tuesday he hit a pinch-hit double to lead off the 10th inning, and scored the go-ahead run. On Wednesday he homered to tie the game, and on Sunday he doubled in the 10th, putting the Indians ahead before the game was suspended.

    Yan Gomes

    Gomes missed the first three games of the week as he recovered from a concussion, but he made up for lost time after his return, picking up 2 hits in Friday's win, an RBI double in Saturday's victory, and 4 hits (and 2 runs scored) in Sunday's game, for a line of .500/.500/.571 in 14 PA.

    Bryan Shaw

    It's not often a reliever can crack this list, but Shaw was awesome last week. Tuesday he got the final 7 outs of the Tribe's 8-6 win, all without allowing any base runners. Thursday he gave up a single, and should have been out of the inning without any runs, but an error by Mike Aviles prolonged the inning a one run did score, unearned. He pitched a scoreless inning Friday night, and another Sunday. 5.0 IP altogether, with 0 ER and only 3 base runners.

    The Winner

    This was a tough call for me. I think Chisenhall was the top offensive performer of the week, especially if you give extra credit for the timing of his production (which for this honor, I do), with many of his hits coming at key moments. Carrasco's start was great, and every time he pitches like that I have more confidence in him, something I've felt little of when watching him as a starter over the year. I think Shaw's relief work was an even bigger contribution though, especially the 7-out performance from Tuesday. I think Shaw has as good a case for winning this honor as any reliever on the team has had all season.

    In the end though, I'm going with Chisenhall. His WPA of .71 is outstanding, and helps illuminate how big some of his hits were.

    Congratulations to Lonnie!

    -