Regardless of the outcome in Baltimore, the Indians will remain tied for the Wild Card lead thanks to a Boston loss. That being said, this was a gigantic missed opportunity. If they had pulled this one out, it would have made their lives a whole lot easier.
Now the Indians almost have to win the last two games of this series AND take at least two out of three against the White Sox to assure themselves at least a one-game playoff.
Update [2005-9-27 23:59:13 by Ryan]: Now that the Yankees have lost, winning 3 of 5 guarantees at least a playoff game.